Locator: 44834WTI.
I understand oil is a commodity and I understand the concept of fungibility, but I can't but think this development won't be / will be bullish for American shale companies.
Locator: 44834WTI.
I understand oil is a commodity and I understand the concept of fungibility, but I can't but think this development won't be / will be bullish for American shale companies.
Oil: America's new benchmark. Link here. Previously reported but now a bit of the back story and Harold Hamm is center stage. Thank you to a reader. Great story!
American shale oil has a new benchmark, and a driving force behind it is one of the Bakken’s own.
The new benchmark is called American GulfCoast Select (AGS) and Continental’s Harold Hamm is among its architects.
The new benchmark was designed to rival the landlocked U.S. West Texas Intermediate futures contract, which is based on delivery to Cushing, Oklahoma, and which has typically been used to reflect the value of a barrel of Bakken crude oil.
The delivery location for WTI, however, is 500 miles from water, and that has led to market distortions in the past. Most notably, it led to negative $38-dollar futures contracts last year during the pandemic.
Brent, meanwhile, is priced on an island in the North Sea, with immediate access to tanker storage. That insulates Brent from market distortion like that caused by the supply glut caused by the Saudi-Russian price war during the pandemic.
The new benchmark is based on Gulf Coast delivery instead of a land-locked location, essentially giving shale a Brent of its own. That will better reflect shale oil’s value in the world market, and should prevent market distortions due to lack of storage infrastructure.
Hamm, in a recent editorial circulated by the Montana Petroleum Association, said the negative future contracts for WTI were a wake-up that the situation at Cushing, Oklahoma, through which a lot of Bakken crude oil still travels, was no longer tenable.
Platts AGS reflects the value of light sweet crude oil loading 15-45 days forward on an FOB basis from locations along the US Gulf Coast including Houston, Corpus Christi, Beaumont, Nederland, Texas City, and Port Arthur, with the most competitive location on a cargo-size normalized basis setting the price assessment.
This crude oil assessment reflects a typical cargo size of 700,000 barrels, with bids, offers and trades between 550,000 and 800,000 barrels eligible for use in the assessment but normalized to reflect the freight economics of the typical cargo size. The assessment reflects the Platts WTI Midland grade supplied directly from the Permian Basin on the BridgeTex, Longhorn, Midland-to-Echo I/II, Cactus I/II, EPIC, Gray Oak, and Permian Express pipelines with API between 40 and 44 and .2% sulfur limit, among other specifications.
And here, if I'm reading the story correctly, AGS runs about $1.00 to $2.00 over Brent.
NDIC: active rigs up and running:
| $53.02 | 1/12/2021 | 01/12/2020 | 01/12/2019 | 01/12/2018 | 01/12/2017 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Active Rigs | 10 | 55 | 67 | 56 | 36 |
| Rig | Operator | Well Name and Number | Current Location | County | File No | API | Start Date | ** Next Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| H & P 515 | PETRO-HUNT, L.L.C. | HAGEN 144-98-12C-1- 1H | NENW 13-144N-98W | BIL | 36077 | 33007019170000 | 12/30/2020 | Undetermined |
| CYCLONE 38 | CONTINENTAL RESOURCES, INC. | Gale 8-32H1 | NWNE 32-147N-96W | DUN | 37399 | 33025040080000 | 1/6/2021 | Undetermined |
| NABORS B27 | WPX ENERGY WILLISTON, LLC | Dakota 1-36HY | SWSE 1-149N-93W | DUN | 37832 | 33025040830000 | 1/7/2021 | Undetermined |
| NABORS B6 | BURLINGTON RESOURCES OIL & GAS COMPANY LP | F JORGENSON 1D MBH | SESW 11-151N-97W | MCK | 37480 | 33053093720000 | 1/9/2021 | Undetermined |
| NABORS x10 | MARATHON OIL COMPANY | Black USA 11-35H | SWNE 34-152N-94W | MCK | 37610 | 33053094390000 | 1/8/2021 | Bullseye |
| UNIT 414 | SLAWSON EXPLORATION COMPANY, INC. | STALLION 3-1-12H | LOT3 1-151N-93W | MTL | 36125 | 33061044220000 | 1/3/2020 | Undetermined |
| H & P 492 | MARATHON OIL COMPANY | Etherington USA 34-31TFH | SWSE 31-151N-93W | MTL | 37675 | 33061047650000 | 1/8/2021 | Undetermined |
| H & P 259 | MARATHON OIL COMPANY | Watterberg USA 41-5TFH | LOT4 4-150N-93W | MTL | 37787 | 33061047980000 | 1/5/2021 | Undetermined |
| NABORS X28 | HESS BAKKEN INVESTMENTS II, LLC | BL-A IVERSON- 155-96-1312H-8 | NWNE 24-155N-96W | WIL | 36770 | 33105052780000 | 12/26/2020 | Undetermined |
| NABORS B13 | OASIS PETROLEUM NORTH AMERICA LLC | Cliff Federal 5300 43-35 5B | SWSE 35-153N-100W | WIL | 37266 | 33105053960000 | 1/6/2021 | Undetermined |
This could all be greatly affected if Russia and Saudi Arabia agree to increase production. We will know more by the end of June / July. "Those" tea leaves suggest Russia and OPEC will raise production using the excuse that loss of production in Iraq, Iran, Venezuela and global demand forecasts for 2019 necessitates such action.Technically I was correct, but in fact, I expected the price of WTI to fall -- short term -- if OPEC/non-OPEC announced an increase in production. On that I was wrong.
Go back to the sixteen reasons -- and play the song while you are at. None of the sixteen reasons have changed. This is what is new, what happened today. Saudi Arabia said it will increase production, but Saudi is afraid of overshooting the target again (like they did, 2014 - 2016) and so, in their timidity, raised production so slightly in the big scheme of things, traders/speculators are pretty confident that the oil sector is behind the "eight ball" when it comes to production. Which is very bullish for oil.Why did the "OPEC basket" fall today? I think it has to do with the strength of the dollar.
The Renaissance began in Florence, Italy, in the 14th century. Various theories have been proposed to account for its origins and characteristics, focusing on a variety of factors including the social and civic peculiarities of Florence at the time: its political structure; the patronage of its dominant family, the Medici; and the migration of Greek scholars and texts to Italy following the Fall of Constantinople to the Ottoman Turks. Other major centres were northern Italian city-states such as Venice, Genoa, Milan, Bologna, and finally Rome during the Renaissance Papacy.I was unaware of the close relationship between the Pope and the House of Medici. Pope Eugenius IV moved the pontificate from Rome to Florence in 1434 where the Medici bankers were based.
Asian rice was brought to the Middle East sometime around 1000 B.C., and the most likely route of introduction in Europe was through Spain, conquered by the Moors in the 8th century A.D. Although rice was known to the Romans, and mentioned by Pliny in his Natural History, it was only thought to have some medicinal properties and was not grown by them as a food source.
It was not until the 15th century that rice cultivation spread to Northern Italy, where the fertile swampy plains of the Po river valley provide suitable growing conditions.
In a letter written in 1475 the Duke of Milan claimed that from the one sack of rice he sent as a gift to the Duke of Ferrara 12 sacks could be harvested, if properly cultivated.
This impressive yield led to rice being quickly diffused throughout the region, but up until the mid-19th century only that one variety of rice- called Nostrale- was grown. In 1839 a Jesuit priest, Padre Calleri, returning from the Phillipines imported 43 different rice varieties, and it was from this stock that Italians began to experiment with the varieties that could best be adapted for use in Northern Italy’s temperate climate.From Menzies, p. 204:
In many ways, the Po River resembles a smaller version of the Yangtze. Both rivers carry melting snows from the mountains eastward to the sea. Both suffer from flash floods and are controlled by a network of canals, locks, sluices, and dams. The waters of both are used to form extensive rice field. The exact date when the Po was first utilized for rice is not known (see above). Clearly it predated 1475 but by how much? Menzies suggests it was after 1435 when Taccola's first drawings of pumps appear, and probably after 1438, when his drawings of lock and sluice gates first appear.
U.S. crude inventories fell by 1.1 million barrels last week, short of expectations, but the 10-week streak of declines represents a record, according to U.S. Energy Information Administration data going back to 1982. At 411.6 million barrels, stocks are at their lowest since February 2015. [EIA/S]I replied, not ready for prime time:
And still not even close to the 10-year median (and the 10-year median would have been even lower had it not been for the Saudi surge in production, 2014 - 2016).We're a long way from balancing -- my calculations suggest 20 weeks before we're balanced; no change from last week.In addition, as the price for crude rises, there is a risk Russia and Saudi will start raising production (Saudi will use the excuse they don't want to upset the "synchronized global economy" with expensive gasoline which could cause problems for the economies of China and the US).With a drawdown only 1.1 million bbls, and "short of expectations," my first thought -- but I decided not to post it on the blog (earlier) -- was this the the low point on drawdowns from here on out?All I know is I'm glad we have graphics and not just words.
| 12/11/2016 | 12/11/2015 | 12/11/2014 | 12/11/2013 | 12/11/2012 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Active Rigs | 40 | 65 | 186 | 192 | 183 |
| Date | Oil Runs | MCF Sold |
|---|---|---|
| 10-2016 | 30193 | 60862 |
| 9-2016 | 29500 | 32283 |
| 8-2016 | 22266 | 30588 |
| 7-2016 | 28141 | 34550 |
| 6-2016 | 16005 | 14950 |
| Date | Oil Runs | MCF Sold |
|---|---|---|
| 10-2016 | 24001 | 46703 |
| 9-2016 | 14729 | 19449 |
| 8-2016 | 19827 | 24927 |
| 7-2016 | 24534 | 40337 |
| 6-2016 | 17169 | 20794 |
| Date | Oil Runs | MCF Sold |
|---|---|---|
| 10-2016 | 27811 | 9916 |
| 9-2016 | 28379 | 14961 |
| 8-2016 | 29105 | 13882 |
| 7-2016 | 31212 | 7860 |
| 6-2016 | 8634 | 1164 |
| Date | Oil Runs | MCF Sold |
|---|---|---|
| 10-2016 | 7239 | 20672 |
| 9-2016 | 3813 | 8127 |
| 8-2016 | 8262 | 22092 |
| 7-2016 | 18716 | 37854 |
| 6-2016 | 2677 | 2502 |
| Date | Oil Runs | MCF Sold |
|---|---|---|
| 10-2016 | 22997 | 58071 |
| 9-2016 | 27860 | 52005 |
| 8-2016 | 36588 | 53657 |
| 7-2016 | 40916 | 60777 |
| 6-2016 | 11411 | 15802 |
| 12/11/2016 | 12/11/2015 | 12/11/2014 | 12/11/2013 | 12/11/2012 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Active Rigs | 40 | 65 | 186 | 192 | 183 |
Summary:
Other data points:
- Non-OPEC cuts in oil production total between 612,000 bpd and 558,000 bpd.
- Non-OPEC cuts could take time to play out, as OPEC allowed natural declines to be used as a 2017 oil production cut
- The Saudi Oil Minister stated there could be a more sizable cut announced in the near future
- The Saudis have found the leadership role in OPEC again, and orchestrated a historic cooperative effort with non-OPEC nations
- Oil prices may rise from 15% to 35% over the course of the next 12 months. The initial cut by OPEC caused a 15% increase in the price of oil. This was a short squeeze. $52 proved to be a significant resistance level, as producer hedging has the benefit of contango.
- Contango is a bearish situation that occurs when oil prices are higher in the future. Backwardation is bullish as front month prices are higher.
- Since oil prices are now higher by $3 to $4/bbl over 12 months, operators can hedge production for better forward prices. Operators hedge to guarantee a price for production. This is encouraged by banks. Cap ex plans can be developed, as it provides revenue certainty.
- Operators in the Permian, SCOOP/STACK, core Eagle Ford, and core Bakken see decent returns at $54/bbl or $55/bbl. Producer hedging is creating difficulties breaking to the upside.
- Although many media outlets have reported a 558,000 bpd cut, the 12 nations reporting totaled 612,000 bpd. The OPEC/Non-OPEC cut represents 2% of world production.
- The size and scope of cooperation is significant, and could move trading ranges higher.
- Kazakhstan was a surprise with it's 50,000 bpd cut. It had planned to bring a new field online next year. Significant pressure must have been placed on the country, as the IEA had estimated it would increase production in 2017 by 160,000 bpd. Russian production is also a mystery. It self-reports at 11.2 million bpd.
- Analysts have noted Russian production closer to 10.7 or 10.8 million bpd. It is possible Russia isn't cutting. OPEC has stated it would accept natural declines as cuts. It is possible these cuts may come into effect over time, and not on January 1st.
- Most of the Bakken and Eagle Ford need a steady $60/bbl oil price to increase production. Both plays will continue to see a production decrease. This will offset gains in better plays.
- It is very important to take a look at operator's hedge books before investing. Companies like Continental and EOG Resources are not hedged and will realize the full value of a drop in world crude inventories. Many of the Permian players will report sizeable hedging losses next year if oil takes off. Many have swaps in the mid-40s.
The Brent premium to West Texas Intermediate (WTI) on Friday (October 18, 2013) was $9.14/Bbl – indicating a new disconnect between US crude prices and international levels. Unlike last time a big Brent premium to WTI opened up in 2010 the price of Light Louisiana Sweet at the Gulf Coast is still tracking with WTI rather than following Brent. This suggests that the US Gulf Coast is long crude at the moment and that imports of Brent priced crude are not required. Today we discuss the current Gulf Coast crude market.Note: "imports of Brent-priced crude are not required."
This sudden divergence in the Brent price runs counter to the thinking of many analysts. That is because it signals that US Gulf refineries currently have adequate crude supplies and do not need imported barrels – certainly of light crude but also of medium grades as well - i.e. any crudes with prices linked to Brent. If there were demand for these imported barrels then theoretically the price of LLS would be tracking closer to Brent because those imports would compete with LLS for the attention of Gulf Coast refiners.
With LLS at a near $6/Bbl discount to Brent the Gulf Coast is not attracting imports.Why is that such a shock? After all, US production has been increasing in leaps and bounds and we know that a lot of shale crude has been arriving at Gulf Coast refineries from North Dakota, the Permian Basin and the Eagle Ford. The reason for the surprise is that Gulf Coast refineries were (up until early October) running at over 90 percent of capacity and although more domestic crude is making its way to the region, most believed that refiners still need plenty of imported supplies to make up their feedstock requirements.
But this week, prices seem to be telling us that the Gulf Coast is awash with crude supplies. LLS crude is trading at a $3/Bbl premium to WTI – less than the cost of transport from Cushing to the Louisiana Gulf Coast (where LLS is delivered at St. James). The Houston price for WTI is tracking neck and neck with LLS. So Louisiana refiners are getting adequate supplies from local offshore production, barges from Corpus Christi or rail from North Dakota and have no need for Cushing barrels. In any case the current work to reverse the Ho-Ho pipeline means there is no pipeline link from Houston to St James. Even heavy crudes look to be over supplied at the Gulf Coast at the moment.
The price of two heavy sour grades – West Texas Sour and Southern Green Canyon - were discounted last week by more than $7/Bbl to WTI due to low demand for these crudes by Houston refineries. In short – Houston and Louisiana Gulf Coast refineries appear to have plenty of crude.