Thursday, December 4, 2025

With Most Of Its Best Well Sites Already Drilled, Are The Bakken's Best Days Behind It? RBN Energy -- Bakken -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49625B.

Link here

A new, AI-based analysis suggests that while Bakken crude oil production is humming along at a steady 1.2 MMb/d, about 75% of the shale play’s top-quartile locations have already been drilled and only 6,100 well sites — about six years of inventory at the current drilling pace — could generate a good return at the prices we’ve seen the past couple of years. That raises a long list of questions. Are the Bakken’s best days behind it? Which producers are well-positioned from a best-rock perspective, and which are less so? And what would happen if crude oil prices were to settle in below $60/bbl? In today’s RBN blog, we’ll discuss highlights from Novi Labs’ fresh take on the U.S.’s second-largest onshore production area. 

Last year, in You Don’t Know Me, we recapped the Bakken’s extraordinary rise during the early years of the Shale Revolution. From 2009 to 2015, crude oil production in western North Dakota and the eastern edge of Montana increased 6X, to 1.2 MMb/d — a growth rate so outrageous that more than two-thirds of the oil produced there in 2013-14 needed to be loaded into tank cars and railed out. (Takeaway pipeline capacity didn’t catch up ’til 2017.) A mid-decade price crash trimmed Bakken production to less than 1 MMb/d, but by 2019 E&Ps had pushed the basin’s output to a record 1.4 MMb/d. Then came Covid, another price crash and another rebound — this time only to the 1.2-MMb/d level where production stands today.

As shown in Figure 1 below, the vast majority of Bakken crude production comes from four North Dakota counties: McKenzie (dark-blue layer), Williams (magenta layer), Dunn (red layer) and Mountrail (orange layer)

 

Musical Interlude -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49624MUSIC.

I remember growing up to these songs, and yet my mom seldom played any music in the house. I would have been under the age of ten when these songs came out, and yet, I don't recall where I would have been listening to them.  

"TLC Tender Love and Care," Jimmie Rodgers, link here. 1959, or thereabouts. 


And another one. Link here. "Honeycomb." 1957.

Four New Permits -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49623B.
Locator: 49623COWBOYS.

Dallas Cowboys: at Detroit Lions. Finally it gets interesting -- a trifecta -- Dak Prescott with two wide receivers -- all at their prime coming together -- CeeDee Lamb and George Pickens. All of a sudden, "overnight," they have become NFL sensations. Can hardly wait to watch tonight's game -- exclusively on Amazon Prime.  [Later: 46 seconds into the second half, 27 - 9. It's the Detroit Lions' game to lose. Wow. With all the talent the Cowboys have how can they keep losing?] Wow. 

Texas politics: US Supreme Court okays Texas redistricting plan. Would help ensure GOP holding the US House. Five additional seats in play.  

**************************
Back to the Bakken

WTI: $59.70.

Active rigs: 31.

Four new permits, #42537 - #42540, inclusive;

  • Operators: Oasis (3), Phoenix Operating
  • Fields: Tyrone (Williams County); Kittleson Slough (Mountrail County)
  • Comments:
    • Phoenix Operating has a permit for a Pladson well, SeSe 33-158-91,
      • to be sited 425 FSL and 1220 FEL;
    • Oasis has permits for three Goose wells, NENW 7-156-101,
      •  to be sited 290 / 356 FNL and 1652 FWL. 

Dow Theory Bellwether Stock? December 4, 2025

Locator: 49622INVESTING.

Ticker UNP:


 

Apple's M5 Chip -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49621APPLE.

Link here


Amazon Just Unveiled Its Second Chip This Week -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49620AMAZON.

Link here


 

This Is Almost Embarrassing -- Amazon Already Has Same Day Delivery, Often Faster -- Now Looking To 30-Minute Delivery -- Meanwhile Target -- They're Trying To Get Next-Day Delivery -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49619TARGET.

Link here


Apple Arcade Just Got The Most Downloaded Mobile Game Ever -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49618APPLE.

Minor data point in big scheme of things, but an interesting data point for Apple.

Link here

Microsoft To Increase Prices Of Office Productivity Software Subscriptions -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49617MSFT.

This is absolutely crazy but exactly why I invest in MSFT.

But I only use Apple products. Never have to pay for part of an Apple suite or whatever they're called. 

But with Microsoft I would be nickeled an dimed until death.  

Link here

What a racket; what a great business model.


What a racket.  

Legacy Fund -- November, 2025 Deposits -- Posted December 4, 2025

Locator: 49616LEGACY.

North Dakota State Legacy Fund. 

Link here




Nvidia -- Too Much Cash -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49615NVDA.

Link here


Amazon -- So Much Cash -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49614AMZN.

Link here


 

Time For The Disclaimer -- December 4, 2025

Much longer version: link here.

*********************************
Disclaimer
Brief Reminder 

Briefly:

  • I am inappropriately exuberant about the Bakken and I am often well out front of my headlights. I am often appropriately accused of hyperbole when it comes to the Bakken.
  • I am inappropriately exuberant about the US economy and the US market.
  • I am also inappropriately exuberant about all things Apple. 
  • See disclaimer. This is not an investment site. 
  • Disclaimer: this is not an investment site. Do not make any investment, financial, job, career, travel, or relationship decisions based on what you read here or think you may have read here. 
  • All my posts are done quickly: there will be content and typographical errors. If something appears wrong, it probably is. Feel free to fact check everything.
  • If anything on any of my posts is important to you, go to the source. If/when I find typographical / content errors, I will correct them. 
  • Many posts are not proofread for several days after they've been posted.  
  • Reminder: I am inappropriately exuberant about the Bakken, US economy, and the US market.
  • I am also inappropriately exuberant about all things Apple. 
  • And now, Nvidia, also. I am also inappropriately exuberant about all things Nvidia. Nvidia is a metonym for AI and/or the sixth industrial revolution.
  • I've now added Broadcom to the disclaimer. I am also inappropriately exuberant about all things Broadcom.
  • And Oracle. 
  • Longer version here.

Back To Energy -- Natural Gas Breakout -- Many Ways To Invest -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49613NG.

Ticker WMB, for long term holders, paying much more than then indicated 4%:

Ticker EPD, pays almost 7%:

Maybe VNOM.

Walmart Trending Toward A Trillion-Dollar Market Cap -- One Of The Few Retailers That Has Figured Out AI -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49612WMT.

The other day in a throwaway line to a reader, I wrote: I don't lose sleep when I add new money to any of these three companies: WMT, MCD, or AMZN. 

Ticker WMT:


AI:  

Random Update -- Enerplus Wells In Moccasin Creek -- Three Pads -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49611B.
Locator: 49611ENERPLUS.

The maps:


 



The wells:

  • 37890, loc/A, Enerplus, Bismuth 147-93-17B-20H, Moccasin Creek, t--; cum 384K 10/25;
  • 37891, loc/A, Enerplus, Cadmium 147-93-17B-20H, Moccasin Creek, t--; cum 143K 10/25;
  • 37892, loc/A, Enerplus, Brass 147-93-17B-20H, Moccasin Creek, t--; cum 312K 10/25;
  • 37893, loc/A, Enerplus, Tin 147-93-17B-20H, Moccasin Creek, t--; cum 342K 10/25;
  • 37894, loc/A, Enerplus, Osmium 147-93-17B-20H, Moccasin Creek, t--; cum 367K 10/25;
  • 37895, loc/A, Enerplus, Gallium 147-93-17A-20H, Moccasin Creek, t--; cum 294K 10/25;

 

  • 37366, drl/A, Enerplus, Amphibolite 147-93-08D-05H, Moccasin Creek, t--; cum 267K 10/25;
  • 36225, drl/A, Enerplus, Hornfels 147-93-08D-05H, Moccasin Creek, t--; cum 216K 10/25;
  • 36226, loc/A, Enerplus, Mylonite 147-93-08D-05H-TF, Moccasin Creek, t--; cum 302K 10/25;
  • 36229, drl/A, Enerplus, Slate 147-93-08D-05H-TF, Moccasin Creek, t--; cum 343K 10/25;
  • 36231, drl/A, Enerplus, Argillite 147-93-08D-05H, Moccasin Creek, t--; cum 245K 10/25;
  • 36227, loc/PNC, Enerplus, Eclogite ... Moccasin Creek, 
  • 36228, loc/PNC, Enerplus, Phyllite ... Moccasin Creek, 
  • 36230, loc/loc, Enerplus, Quartzite 147-93-17A-20H-TF, Moccasin Creek, t--; cum --;
  • 36232, loc/loc, Enerplus, Marble 147-93-17A-20H, Moccasin Creek, t--; cum --;
  • 36233, loc/loc, Enerplus, Gneiss 147-93-17A-20H-TF-LL, Moccasin Creek, t--; cum --;


  • 33967, 3,162, Enerplus, Cobalt 147-93-09D-04H, Mocassin Creek, t7/18; cum 504K 10/25;
  • 33968, 932, Enerplus, Nickel 147-93-16B-21H-TF, Mocassin Creek, t8/18; cum 307K 10/25;
  • 33969, 1,077, Enerplus, Steel 147-93-09D-04H-TF, Mocassin Creek, t8/18; cum 377K 10/25;
  • 33970, 2,038, Enerplus, Tungsten 147-93-16A-21H, Mocassin Creek, t7/18; cum 418K 10/25;
  • 33971, 2,631, Enerplus, Zinc 147-93-09D-04H, Mocassin Creek, t7/18; cum 427K 10/25;
  • 33972, 1,126, Enerplus, Lead 147-93-16B-21H-TF, Mocassin Creek, t7/18; cum 411K 10/25;
  • 37583, loc/PNC, Enerplus, Silver 147-93-09D-04H, Mocassin Creek, 
  • 33974, loc/A, Enerplus, Silver 147-93-09D-04H, Mocassin Creek, t--; cum 119K 10/25;
  • 37584, loc/A, Enerplus, Niobium 147-93-09D-04H, Mocassin Creek, t--; cum 70K 10/25;
  • 33973, loc/A, Enerplus, Titanium 147-93-16A-21H, Mocassin Creek, t--; cum 141K 10/25;
  • 37585, loc/A, Enerplus, Yttrium 147-93-16A-21H, Mocassin Creek, t--; cum 270K 10/25;
  • 33975, loc/PNC, Enerplus, Platinum... Mocassin Creek, 
  • 37586, loc/A, Enerplus, Silver 147-93-09D-04H, Mocassin Creek, t--; cum 119K 10/25;

Tokens Per Second Vs Chip Density -- The New Metric -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49610CHIPS.

AI promptSemiconductor density (transistor count) seems to have been the metric to follow as recently as a year ago, but now, the metric to follow appears to be the number of tokens that can be processed per second. Is there any accuracy to that statement?

Google Gemini:
 
 

Chinese Computer -- Lenovo -- Flagged By Yahoo Moments Ago For Best Buy Ever -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49609LENOVO.

Before proceeding, it should be noted: Semiconductor density (transistor count) seems to have been the metric to follow as recently as a year ago, but now, the metric to follow appears to the number of tokens that can be processed per second. Google Gemini agrees with that statement. 




In other words, the Lenovo advertised below cannot "do" AI. On the other hand, the Apple M4 chip is optimized for AI.  

Best price ever. Generally goes for $2,500. Being sold now for $599. Okay. 

From Yahoo:

From Amazon


My wife's state-of-the-art, AI-ready, Apple MacBook AI 13-inch, priced at $999 by Apple is being sold for $749 over at Amazon. 

The Intel Celeron chip in the Lenovo pictured above:


I have no idea who the target audience would be.

The M4 was released in May, 2025, using 3-nm technology.  

A reminder:

Random Update Of 10-Well Pad In Heart Butte -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49608B.

See this post

On the south side of the river, going north, these two five-well pads:

  • 23102, 1,966, Oasis, MHA 4-06-32H-150-92, Heart Butte, t2/13; cum 462K 10/25;
  • 23101, 1,777, Oasis, MHA 1-06-32H-150-92, Heart Butte, t2/13; cum 516K 10/25;
  • 23100, 1,922, Oasis, MHA 3-06-32H-150-92, Heart Butte, t2/13; cum 445K 10/25;
  • 23099, 1,994, Oasis, MHA 2-06-32H-150-92, Heart Butte, t2/13; cum 390K 10/25;
  • 23098, 1,632, Oasis, MHA 4-06-32H-150-92, Heart Butte, t2/13; cum 269K 10/25;
  • 23097, 2,512, Oasis, MHA 2-06-31H-150-92, Heart Butte, t9/13; cum 684K 10/25;
  • 23096, 825, Oasis, MHA 1-06-31H-150-92, Heart Butte, t9/13; cum 187K 10/25;
  • 23095, 2,045, Oasis, MHA 5-06-31H-150-92, Heart Butte, t9/13; cum 234K 10/25;
  • 23094, 2,512, Oasis, MHA 2-06-31H-150-92, Heart Butte, t9/13; cum 343K 10/25;
  • 23093, 2,052, Oasis, MHA 3-06-31H-150-92, Heart Butte, t9/13; cum 692K 10/25; halo effect, huge jump in production 8/17; 

Well of interest:

  • 18322, 1,742, Oasis/Questar Exploration, MHA 1-06-31H-150-92, Heart Butte, t6/10; cum 652K 10/25; open hole frack; 52,351 bbls fluid; 3,340,436 lbs proppant; 

Holy Mackerel! META Is Not Even In The Top 25 Among LLM -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49607LLAMA.

Updates

December 4, 2025: I've never seen one analyst recommending META wearing META's AI Ray-Ban glasses. Not one. I have seen talking heads on CNBC wearing AirPods. 

December 4, 2025: as the day wore on, CNBC talking heads became more and more negative regarding Mark Zuckerberg's pivot to the Metaverse a couple of years ago. Huge mistake in the eyes of CNBC analysts. The losses of the Meta reality labs have been incredibly awful. Mark Zuckerberg sees Apple as its main competitor. In fact, for investors, the latter see Google as Meta's biggest worry.

Ticker META:  

Original Post  

Llama 4.0 was a disaster.

META not even in the top 25 chatbots any more.

Google Gemini is #1 with OpenAI close behind (at the moment).

China is catching up quickly.

Talking head / analyst on CNBC following META report earlier today. 

AI has moved so far ahead now, and hardware is not where AI is right now. Zuckerberg recognizes that and made huge decision, reported earlier. 

From AI today:




 

New Devon Energy Well South Of New Town, ND -- Three Forks -- Under The Water -- 75,000 Bbls Crude Oil In First 30 Days -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49606B.

The wells:

  • 35456, con-->drl/A, Oasis/QEP, MHA 5-29-30H-150-92, Van Hook, first production, 5/21; t--; cum 302K 4/22; see production profile herecum 549K 10/25;
  • 35454, conf-->drl/A, Oasis/QEP, MHA 5-27-26H-150-92, Van Hook, first production, 5/21; t--; cum 199K 4/22;
  • 35451, conf-->loc/A, Oasis/QEP, MHA 4-29-30H-150-92, Van Hook, first production, 5/21; t--; cum 342K 4/22; cum 686K 10/15; Three Forks, 50 stages; 328,865 bbls; 14,337,846 lbs of proppant -- compare to #40389 below.
  • 35449, conf-->loc/A, Oasis/QEP, MHA 4-27-26H-150-92, Van Hook, first production, 5/21; t--; cum 239K 4/22; cum 437K 10/25;
These wells led me to this relatively new 10-well pad: 
  • 40394, drl/A, Devon Energy, Missouri River 25-26HUL, Reunion Bay, t--; cum 207K 10/25;
  • 40393, drl/A, Devon Energy, Missouri River 25-26HD, Reunion Bay, t--; cum 245K 10/25;
  • 40392, drl/A, Devon Energy, Missouri River 25-26HZ, Reunion Bay, t--; cum 274K 10/25;
  • 40391, drl/A, Devon Energy, Missouri River 25-26HB, Reunion Bay, t--; cum 276K 10/25;
  • 40390, drl/A, Devon Energy, Missouri River 25-26HX, Reunion Bay, t--; cum 301K 10/25;
  • 40237, drl/A, Devon Energy, Missouri River 25-26HC, Reunion Bay, t--; cum 298K 10/25;
  • 40389, drl/A, Devon Energy, Missouri River 25-26HW, Reunion Bay, t--; cum 303K 10/25;
  • 40388, drl/A, Devon Energy, Missouri River 25-26HA, Reunion Bay, t--; cum 288K 10/25;
  • 40387, drl/A, Devon Energy, Missouri River 25-26HY, Reunion Bay, t--; cum 269K 10/25;
  • 40386, drl/A, Devon Energy, Missouri River 25-26HIL, Reunion Bay, t--; cum 181K 10/25;

Example of production profile. Located 12.3 miles south of New Town, ND. Under the water. 

  • 40389, drl/A/2,436, Devon Energy, Missouri River 25-26HW, Reunion Bay, t--; cum 303K 10/25; spud June 28, 2024; completed on July 9, 2025; the target stipulated by the Devon geologist was 20' below the top of the Three Forks; 34 stages; 116,658 bbls fluid; 8,460,270 lbs proppant (incredibly low amount of proppant); max treatment PSI: 9,425;
PoolDateDaysBBLS OilRunsBBLS WaterMCF ProdMCF SoldVent/Flare
BAKKEN10-202530978498007675183311827952
BAKKEN9-202526966196756678273142727836
BAKKEN8-20253113037129698632348543476688
BAKKEN7-202531150341503910990331593314217
BAKKEN6-202530186641865013745344453440639
BAKKEN5-202525219062193214388265242649925
BAKKEN4-2025303528135254218994701946850169
BAKKEN3-20253141476414442986242693426849
BAKKEN2-20252723516236022162321475214750
BAKKEN1-2025293672136580312503146830715753
BAKKEN12-20244385540553394327732752
BAKKEN11-202430744797424160427652216520813

Chart Of The Day -- The Copper Gap -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49605COPPER.

Link here

**************************
Chokepoints

Previously posted: 

Chatbot and LDC chokepoints:

  • right now: access to blades; [adding memory (MU) -- December 4, 2025]
  • the next twelve months: putting blades on-line; 
    • Nvidia, AMD, copper, fiberoptics
  • next few years with the large data center build-out: cooling;
  • five to seven years: access to affordable electricity. 

Boring, Boring, Boring -- Ennui -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49604AMAZON.

I woke up today absolutely bored with current events and the market. Not interested in blogging.

Then I saw this. This may be the biggest story today. And, of course, tonight, Amazon Prime's exclusive TNF tonight with the Dallas Cowboys and the Detroit Lions. Whoo-hoo. 

But for the market, this may be the biggest story all day: Amazon -- taking a page from Apple's business model -- don't rely on third parties --


 

*****************************
META Tweaks Priorities

Zuckerberg plans deep cuts for metaverse -- report. Analysts continue to note that Meta is losing tons of money on those Ray-Ban glasses. META surges on news. See this post.

**********************
The Worst Ad On CNBC Right Now

Has been running for months. Nuveen. 

Visuals awful. Fashion disaster. No message. 

Actually, I spoke too soon. The "SelectQuote" ad is even worse, much worse, but for other reasons. The ad perpetuates at least one meme and one racial stereotype. 

**************************
Costco -- COST -- At A 52-Week Low 

Journalists' Naivete -- The New York Times -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49603ARCHIVES.

Link here

Read that article at The New York Times and see if you see what I see with regard to the naivete of journalists and the immigrant story. At the link, scroll down to "Collective Blame."

This is simply amazing and very, very scary -- the naivete of journalists. 

Jobless Claims Come In Incredibly Low -- Hitting Recent Records -- Thursday -- December 4, 2025

Locator: 49602B.

Jobless claims: incredibly low. Completely unexpected. The numbers are incredibly low. Of course that moved the markets down.


*******************************************
Back to the Bakken

WTI: $59.36.

New wells reporting:
  • Friday, December 5, 2025: 12 for the month, 135 for the quarter, 719 for the year, 
    • 41242, conf, Hess, GO-Bergstrom-156-98-2833H-7, 
    • 41777, conf, CLR, Willey 7-3H, 
  • Thursday, December 4, 2025: 10 for the month, 133 for the quarter, 717 for the year,
    • 41776, conf, CLR, Willey 6-3H,

A federal judge in Delaware on November 29 signed the sale agreement on a $5.9 billion cash bid from hedge fund Elliott Investment Management to purchase three coveted CITGO refineries, along with a number of associated midstream assets. This is the latest — and potentially last — turn in an eight-year legal fight over CITGO’s parent, PDV Holding, and names Elliott affiliate Amber Energy as the winning bidder for the plants, which have a combined refining capacity of more than 800 Mb/d. In today’s RBN blog, we’ll discuss Amber’s plans for the CITGO refineries.

Let’s start with some background. As we detailed in I’ll Be Around, there’s been a primarily below-the-radar battle playing out in the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware since 2017 about how best to help satisfy the claims of a dozen-plus creditors who collectively lost more than $20 billion when the government of Venezuela — the de facto owner of CITGO Petroleum and its parent company, PDV Holding (PDVH) — defaulted on its bonds. (In 2019, control of CITGO was transferred away from the ruling Maduro regime in Venezuela to the opposition “shadow” government, then led by Juan Guaidó.) In May 2021, U.S. District Court Judge Leonard P. Stark appointed Robert B. Pincus as a special master tasked with devising a plan to sell PDVH/CITGO to satisfy at least some portion of the outstanding claims. After a two-round bidding process that concluded in June 2024, Pincus recommended in September 2024 that the district court approve Amber Energy and its $7.3 billion bid for CITGO and its three refineries (Lake Charles, LA; Lemont, IL; and Corpus Christi, TX). However, instead of ending the drama, the court restarted the bidding from scratch in December 2024, citing issues with the auction process.

As a result of the new bidding round, the court in July recommended a $7.4 billion bid from Dalinar Energy, the U.S. subsidiary of Canadian miner Gold Reserve. But by August 30, that deal was overtaken by what the court described as a “superior” proposal from Amber Energy — even though its bid included less cash. (Amber’s offer included $5.86 billion in cash and $2.86 billion in strategic debt settlements; together with $105 million of break fees paid to writ holders, it equates to a total value of $8.821 billion.) Pincus approved Amber’s bid, saying that Dalinar’s proposal did not match or exceed it despite a last-minute attempt to improve the terms (Dalinar later raised its bid to $7.9 billion).

Earlier this fall, several parties were pushing to scrap the auction and start from scratch (again). Judge Stark heard testimony on October 21-22 from CITGO, PDVH and the Venezuelan government, which argued that Amber Energy’s bid was far too low. But on November 25, Stark dismissed the objections and gave Amber the green light, giving parties until November 28 to submit any remaining objections. Several entities filed objections, but the court entered a sale order on November 29 authorizing the transfer of PDVH’s shares to Amber. The transfer is subject to U.S. regulatory and Treasury Department approvals and could face appeals by Venezuela and other parties. The sale is expected to close next year, assuming the required approvals are obtained and any appeals do not result in a reversal. Then, proceeds will be distributed to Venezuela‑linked creditors in line with the court’s priority schedule.

Before we dive into Amber Energy’s plan, let’s briefly highlight each refinery. The 479-Mb/d Lake Charles Refinery in southwestern Louisiana (refinery icon at bottom of Figure 1 below) is the seventh-largest in the U.S. and CITGO’s most valuable asset. Using various criteria, RBN’s Refined Fuels Analytics (RFA) practice ranks it among the 10 most competitive refineries along the Gulf Coast. The Lake Charles facility is highly complex, with a broad range of downstream processing units, which allow it to profitably process a wide variety of crudes and other feedstocks into valuable refined products, including various grades of gasoline, jet fuel, ultra-low-sulfur diesel (ULSD), benzene, propylene and other products. Also, the refinery’s multiple processing trains give it significant additional operating flexibility, enhancing its ability to respond effectively to changing market conditions and crude and product differentials. CITGO completed a very cost-effective, 38-Mb/d expansion of the refinery in Q1 2023 and recently increased capacity by another 16 Mb/d in a similarly efficient way to reach its current level as it continues to invest in the facility to improve its capabilities, competitiveness and market responsiveness.