Updates
April 24, 2016: See North Dakota natural gas production / milestone: http://themilliondollarway.blogspot.com/2016/04/directors-cut-is-out-february-2016-data.html.
Original Post
Disclaimer: my long notes, often done quickly, are not always proofread the first time they are posted. There may be typographical errors, and there may be factual errors, but hopefully folks can understand the point I'm trying to make. Except for the data at the bottom of the post, this is all opinion.
Motley Fool is reporting a solution to the flaring problem as espoused by certain Bakken operators:
mega-pads with a single natural gas pipeline going to the mega-pad.
I am going out on a limb here, beyond my comfort zone, because I could be way, way wrong, but I was told that unlike crude oil which can go directly into a local line and then into a region/national line, natural gas cannot be shipped via regional/national pipeline until it has been processed.
Again, I am being told that natural gas must first be gathered
and processed by a processing plant before it can be placed in the "national natural gas pipeline system."
Natural gas can only (for all intents and purposes) be flared or removed from the well by pipeline; trucks are not used in the Bakken to transport natural gas from the well head.
If that is accurate, and again, I could be way, way wrong, but if that is accurate, one can easily tell from the NDIC "ticket stubs" whether wells are flaring and, to some extent,
why they are flaring.
1. The first thing to do is look to see if any natural gas is being produced, sold, and/or flared. If natural gas is being produced/sold and absolutely none, zero, nada, zilch, is being flared, one can safely assume the well is hooked up to a pipeline.
2. Even if a well is hooked up to a natural gas pipeline, natural gas might still be flared. If a ticket stub shows that some natural gas is being sold, and some being flared, then one can safely assume that the well is hooked up to a natural gas line, but for some reason, not all of the natural gas was sold; some was flared.
3. If that's the case, some was sold, and some was flared, there is no way to know why. There are two main reasons: a) the processing plant was down for maintenance; b) the processing plant had reached capacity. I think there are ways to sort that out using just the ticket stubs, but it would be difficult, time-consuming, and still, just an educated guess.
So, with all that in mind, I picked, entirely random a starting point to pick ten Bakken wells. I picked #19001 to be the starting point. I could have picked #18000 or #17957 or #19745 or #25687, but I chose to pick #19001. Go with it.
I then took the first ten wells that were productive (#19003 was dry). The data is below. I only took enough data to determine whether the well was hooked up to a natural gas pipeline. Again, I am way beyond my expertise here and it's possible this whole post is inaccurate, but let's continue.
If I am correct, all ten (10) of the wells below are hooked up to a natural gas pipeline, and to a processing plant.
All ten (10) wells are by operators well established in the Bakken, so they understand the flaring issue.
All ten (10) wells are in the heart of the Bakken; no one can say these wells are in the remote sections of the North Dakota Bakken. In fact, some of the fields are downright saturated with Bakken wells: Sanish, Indian Hill, Van Hook, and especially Stockyard Creek east of Williston.
So, plenty of time, densely situated, and all hooked up to a natural gas pipeline, and yet eight of them still flare gas. Either the processing plants were down for maintenance (which is possible in some cases) or the processing plants were at capacity.
But simply placing more natural gas pipelines to mega-pads, as the article linked above suggests, seems not to be as simple as it sounds. We need to see some more natural gas processing plants being built. Don tells me (while writing this note), that it is fairly "easy" to expand existing natural gas processing plants, and if the mega-pad solution works, we should see new processing plants being built. So, we'll see. But just more pipeline is not the answer. (And maybe, to defend
Motley Fool who are much smarter than I, they are implying that "natural gas pipeline" means the entire natural gas gathering
and processing system.)
Again, I'm way out on a limb here; I could be way wrong, but this is how I learn about the Bakken. It is based on what readers have told me.
Two problems I have with the
Motley Fool article. First this from the article:
The most effective way to do this would be, of course, to install
natural gas pipelines to each pad, but, again, the amount of gas coming
from a well or two makes it a very uneconomical decision. If you could
install a gathering pipe for several wells, then you have a chance at
making it happen.
The fields where these wells are located are saturated with wells; it's already equivalent to pad drilling and we still don't see an adequate number of natural gas processing plants, or better said, I suppose, an adequate capacity.
And the second point is simply a pet peeve.
Motley Fool:
In fact, gas flaring is so prevalent in the region that it can be seen from space.
In fact, one can see a lit cigarette from space. "Gas flaring is so prevalent in the [Bakken] that it can be seen from space." That quote is perpetuating a myth that the photo taken of the Bakken from space streamed around the world was, in fact, about 90% lighting from rigs and man-made structures associated with wells, farms, and communities; and, maybe 10% was actually flared gas. But
all that "light" from the Bakken at night is hardly due to flaring natural gas. Just a pet peeve.
Anyway, here's the data. Ten (10) wells that have been around long enough to have had natural gas pipelines in place; in dense enough areas to warrant natural gas processing plants, and more than enough time to make it happen, and yet, of these ten wells, eight wells still flare, and in some cases, significantly so.
By the way, a takeaway from this little exercise: the operators have done their part in all ten of these wells: they have hooked up their wells to a natural gas pipeline. It is the "system" that has let them down, inadequate natural gas processing plants/capacity.
Again, this is my 2 cents worth, coming from someone with no formal education, training, or experience in the oil and gas industry, so I could be way wrong, but I'll throw it out there for consideration.
Hess, by the way, has a very, very strong natural gas history and it is not surprising that one of the two wells noted below that is not flaring, is a Hess well. The other one is a Slawson well, on the reservation, and in a fairly active area.
******************************
19001, 618, Zenergy, Stepanek 8-5H, Indian Hill, t12/10; cum 151K 9/13:
Pool | Date | Days | BBLS Oil | Runs | BBLS Water | MCF Prod | MCF Sold | Vent/Flare |
BAKKEN | 9-2013 | 16 | 695 | 449 | 814 | 673 | 90 | 511 |
BAKKEN | 8-2013 | 30 | 2093 | 2246 | 2350 | 2029 | 312 | 1582 |
19002, 2,130, Statoil, Smith Farm 23-14 1-H, Cow Creek, t10/10; cum 199K 9/13:
Pool | Date | Days | BBLS Oil | Runs | BBLS Water | MCF Prod | MCF Sold | Vent/Flare |
BAKKEN | 9-2013 | 30 | 2912 | 2730 | 3093 | 2270 | 2221 | 49 |
BAKKEN | 8-2013 | 31 | 3309 | 3105 | 3420 | 2684 | 2681 | 3 |
19003, DRY.
19004, 1,440, EOG, Mandaree 12-07H, Squaw Creek:
Pool | Date | Days | BBLS Oil | Runs | BBLS Water | MCF Prod | MCF Sold | Vent/Flare |
BAKKEN | 9-2013 | 30 | 1493 | 1576 | 755 | 1820 | 1508 | 163 |
BAKKEN | 8-2013 | 31 | 1521 | 1427 | 598 | 1676 | 882 | 640 |
19005, 1,289, Whiting, Satterthwaite 43-1H, Sanish, t2/11; cum 127K 9/13:
Pool | Date | Days | BBLS Oil | Runs | BBLS Water | MCF Prod | MCF Sold | Vent/Flare |
BAKKEN | 9-2013 | 30 | 2132 | 2095 | 1008 | 2445 | 2445 | 0 |
BAKKEN | 8-2013 | 31 | 2476 | 2399 | 1350 | 3124 | 3020 | 104 |
19006, 823, KOG, 20711 Kreidle 3229 1H, Stockyard Creek, t7/11; cum 195K 9/13:
Pool | Date | Days | BBLS Oil | Runs | BBLS Water | MCF Prod | MCF Sold | Vent/Flare |
BAKKEN | 9-2013 | 30 | 3813 | 3811 | 4274 | 4242 | 0 | 4152 |
BAKKEN | 8-2013 | 31 | 4331 | 4327 | 3660 | 4201 | 14 | 4098 |
19007, 372, Hess, EN-Will Trust B-157-94-2635H-3, Big Butte, t12/10; cum 69K 9/13:
Pool | Date | Days | BBLS Oil | Runs | BBLS Water | MCF Prod | MCF Sold | Vent/Flare |
BAKKEN | 9-2013 | 5 | 192 | 209 | 230 | 655 | 655 | 0 |
BAKKEN | 8-2013 | 31 | 1254 | 1250 | 937 | 3007 | 3007 | 0 |
19008, 2,804, Statoil, Brakken 30-31 1H, Catwalk, t12/10; cum 164K 9/13:
Pool | Date | Days | BBLS Oil | Runs | BBLS Water | MCF Prod | MCF Sold | Vent/Flare |
BAKKEN | 9-2013 | 30 | 2757 | 2161 | 3001 | 2639 | 0 | 2639 |
BAKKEN | 8-2013 | 30 | 2626 | 3454 | 3532 | 1797 | 0 | 1797 |
BAKKEN | 7-2013 | 31 | 1976 | 1694 | 2648 | 1026 | 0 | 1026 |
BAKKEN | 6-2013 | 17 | 1237 | 625 | 1487 | 573 | 9 | 564 |
BAKKEN | 5-2013 | 31 | 1929 | 2366 | 2712 | 1684 | 6 | 1678 |
BAKKEN | 4-2013 | 30 | 2622 | 2533 | 1975 | 3449 | 48 | 3401 |
BAKKEN | 3-2013 | 31 | 2672 | 2923 | 1948 | 3216 | 0 | 3216 |
BAKKEN | 2-2013 | 28 | 2808 | 2652 | 1854 | 3302 | 19 | 3283 |
BAKKEN | 1-2013 | 29 | 2949 | 2963 | 1544 | 2523 | 482 | 2041 |
19009, 651, CLR, Bonneville 3-23H, Rattlesnake Point, t12/10; cum 199K 9/13:
Pool | Date | Days | BBLS Oil | Runs | BBLS Water | MCF Prod | MCF Sold | Vent/Flare |
BAKKEN | 9-2013 | 30 | 3347 | 3421 | 1450 | 3547 | 3547 | 0 |
BAKKEN | 8-2013 | 31 | 3718 | 3640 | 1533 | 3976 | 3976 | 0 |
BAKKEN | 7-2013 | 31 | 4113 | 4145 | 1775 | 3591 | 3536 | 55 |
BAKKEN | 6-2013 | 21 | 2271 | 2472 | 1092 | 2103 | 2067 | 36 |
BAKKEN | 5-2013 | 31 | 3935 | 4014 | 1719 | 4024 | 3909 | 115 |
19010, 847, Slawson, Armada Federal 1-14-13H, Van Hook, t10/10; cum 245K 9/13:
Pool | Date | Days | BBLS Oil | Runs | BBLS Water | MCF Prod | MCF Sold | Vent/Flare |
BAKKEN | 9-2013 | 30 | 3178 | 2745 | 1848 | 2072 | 1922 | 0 |
BAKKEN | 8-2013 | 10 | 590 | 630 | 1061 | 69 | 19 | 0 |
BAKKEN | 7-2013 | 25 | 3039 | 3398 | 1101 | 1660 | 1410 | 0 |
19011, 725, CLR, Bridger 3-13H, Rattlesnake Point, t12/10; cum 206K 9/13:
Pool | Date | Days | BBLS Oil | Runs | BBLS Water | MCF Prod | MCF Sold | Vent/Flare |
BAKKEN | 9-2013 | 30 | 3544 | 3281 | 862 | 3810 | 3810 | 0 |
BAKKEN | 8-2013 | 31 | 3826 | 3898 | 923 | 4401 | 4401 | 0 |
BAKKEN | 7-2013 | 31 | 3683 | 3700 | 918 | 3564 | 3534 | 30 |
BAKKEN | 6-2013 | 30 | 3878 | 3984 | 947 | 4282 | 4160 | 122 |
BAKKEN | 5-2013 | 31 | 4247 | 4408 | 983 | 4395 | 4275 | 120 |
BAKKEN | 4-2013 | 30 | 4354 | 4221 | 1053 | 4208 | 4208 | 0 |